How to Sell Baseball Cards? Where to Sell it? Best Place to Sell
Updated May 19, 2023
How to Sell Baseball Cards?
Selling baseball cards can be a lucrative way to make some extra money or free up space in your collection. Here are some steps to follow when selling your baseball cards. Baseball card collecting is a popular hobby among sports enthusiasts and collectors alike. Whether you are looking to make some extra money or just trying to downsize your collection, selling baseball cards can be a daunting task. With so many options available, it can be difficult to know where to start.
From online marketplaces to auction houses and local hobby shops, we will explore the pros and cons of each selling option, so you can make an informed decision and get the best value for your cards. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just starting, this guide will help you navigate the world of selling baseball cards.
Where Can I Sell My Baseball Cards
Selling baseball cards can be a highly profitable venture in today's market, far from the days of trading cards on the playground. As of 2019, the sports trading card market was predicted to be worth nearly $14 billion, with an expected value of over $98 billion by 2027. With the industry showing no signs of slowing down, it's essential to know the best places to sell baseball cards for maximum return on investment, whether you're an enthusiastic collector or have stumbled upon a potentially valuable collection.
By understanding the ideal locations to sell baseball cards, whether it be through local sales or online marketplaces, you can save time and effort while ensuring the best possible return on your investment.
Best Place to Sell Base Ball Cards
Gone are the days when having connections with a prominent collector in your area was the only way to sell your baseball cards for cash. With the rise of the internet and the booming trading card market, the question of where to sell collectible baseball cards nearby has become much simpler to answer. Whether you're a collector or just selling for fun, there are now many options available that don't require personal connections.
eBay
One of the earliest and still-active online marketplaces for selling baseball cards is eBay. It provides a global platform to connect with potential customers and collectors worldwide. Selling baseball cards on eBay is a profitable venture as they are among the top items to buy and sell on this platform. Moreover, eBay offers the flexibility to list individual cards or customized bundles, with the option to list up to 50 items for free per day.
However, there are certain costs associated with using eBay, including a fee for each item listed and a 10% commission fee for each successful transaction. Despite this, eBay's massive user base and global reach make it a popular choice for selling baseball cards.
Etsy
If you're looking for an alternative online marketplace to sell your baseball cards, Etsy is worth considering. While it's primarily known for handmade goods and crafts, it also offers a platform for collectors to sell their items. While it may take some effort to build a reputation and reach out to potential buyers, selling baseball cards on Etsy can be profitable in the long run.
Just Collect
Just Collect offers a unique opportunity to sell baseball cards through both in-person transactions and mail-in options. This makes it a great choice for collectors who started collecting baseball cards before 1979. With Just Collect, you can request a free appraisal of your card collection by completing a form on their website. If you have a vintage collection of baseball cards but don't have interested buyers, Just Collect can be an excellent option for you.
If you're looking for a unique way to sell your baseball cards, consider using a subreddit on the popular online forum and web community, Reddit. The subreddit r/baseballcards is an excellent option, as it is well-known for connecting members and facilitating real-life transactions through the subreddit. This is a great way to make money with your collectibles on Reddit. However, it is important to follow the rules of any subreddit you join and avoid spamming or linking your sale listings to any subreddit that prohibits sales or promotional content.
Dean’s Cards
If you are considering selling baseball cards online, whether you are a collector or just have a large number of cards to sell, Dean's Cards is definitely the best place to go. Dean's Cards sells a whopping 1,000 vintage baseball cards every day. The business is open to direct and online sales and is actively seeking collector cards. If your cards date back to before 1969, you can sell them on Dean's Cards. Occasionally, if all the cards are in their original versions from before 1985, Dean's Cards may also purchase entire card sets.
eBid
eBid is a great alternative to eBay if you are looking for a platform to sell your baseball cards at a lower cost with reduced fees or if you want to expand your selling options. With a Trustpilot rating of 4.2, eBid is not only a secure alternative to eBay but also has a positive reputation within its own community.
Bonanza
Bonanza, an online auction site with over 25,000 sellers, offers an alternative to mega-giant auction sites like eBay. While some prefer eBay for its greater visibility and targeted audiences, Bonanza provides a user-friendly experience similar to other online marketplaces. One advantage of using Bonanza to sell your baseball cards is that it does not charge the $0.30 listing fee that eBay does. While this fee may not seem significant, it can quickly add up if you plan to list and sell multiple baseball cards individually.
DA Card World
If you have baseball cards that are still in their original wrapping, DA Card World can help you sell your collection with ease. However, please note that DA Card World only buys whole sports cards that are in their cases or sealed boxes. In certain cases, DA Card World may also purchase modern baseball cards, depending on the type of cards and their demand.
COMC (Check Out My Collectibles)
COMC, short for Check Out My Collectibles, is a renowned online forum catering to gamers, sports card collectors, and comic book enthusiasts. Joining and setting up an account on COMC is completely free, providing you with instant access to all of the community's offerings. Once you have an account, you can begin listing your collections for sale on the site, including individual cards, sets of cards, and bundled packages.
SportsCardPro
If you are searching for a marketplace that specializes in sports and offers a platform for selling your baseball cards, SportsCardPro could be a great option for you. Whether you are a casual hobbyist or a serious collector, you can list and sell your cards on SportsCardPro for free. However, if you choose to sell your cards on this platform, it is important to note that there will be a 2.9% processing fee and a $.30 fee for each sale made on the website.
It's also worth noting that SportsCardPro exclusively uses PayPal for payments, which means that you will need a PayPal account to receive payment.
The Cardboard Connection
The Cardboard Connection is a significant platform for selling baseball cards and other memorabilia, with items fetching prices over $1 million. The site is currently purchasing baseball cards from 1974 and earlier directly from collectors. While the most valuable and in-demand cards tend to be from this time period, The Cardboard Connection also buys recent baseball cards. If you are interested in selling your collection through this platform, you can fill out a form on their official website.
Typically, responses to inquiries are received within 1-2 days, providing ample time to accept or decline the offer before finalizing the sale.
Craigslist
Craigslist is a widely recognized website for advertising goods and services in various markets or specialized industries, providing a platform for connecting with potential buyers and sellers. Although Craigslist is not specifically tailored for buying and selling baseball cards, it does offer a unique opportunity to showcase your collection to a global audience or target specific regions or cities of interest.
Local pawn shops
If you're looking to sell your baseball cards and prefer utilizing local resources and establishments, you may want to consider visiting a neighborhood pawn shop. If you can find a pawn shop that is run by an owner who is passionate about collecting and selling baseball cards, it may be the best option for selling your cards in the local area. Moreover, a pawn shop can often be the most convenient choice if you're looking to receive cash in exchange for your baseball cards.
To begin your search, you can try looking up "pawn shops that buy baseball cards nearby" and go from there.
Local and state fairs
Selling your baseball cards at regional and state fairs can provide a great opportunity to receive cash and gain more exposure for your collection. By selling your cards in person at these events, you can connect with local buyers and even set your own sale price. This can also be an excellent way to network and engage with other collectors and enthusiasts in your community.
Yard sales
If possible, consider selling your baseball cards at a yard sale in your local community. Hosting a neighborhood garage sale not only offers you the opportunity to sell your baseball cards locally, but also allows you to sell other unwanted items from your household or daily life.
What is the best way to sell baseball cards?
When it comes to selling baseball cards for fun and entertainment, there are no hard and fast rules to follow. However, there are a few strategies you can use to increase your chances of successfully closing a deal and getting the price you want for your cards.
Where can I sell my baseball cards for cash?
There are multiple options available for selling your baseball cards for cash:
How to Sell Baseball Cards - FAQs
The most well-liked places to sell baseball cards locally are pawn shops and antique stores.
Yes, since the early 20th century, baseball cards have been a popular collection, and Topps rules the market.
The most recent record price was paid for a 1952 Mickey Mantle baseball card, which came to US$12.6 million.
Selling baseball cards is a fairly simple process that doesn't take a lot of effort or resources.