Who was John Kirby? Know All about John Kirby Nintendo Lawyer

Discover the legacy of John Kirby, the renowned attorney behind Nintendo's iconic Donkey Kong victory, whose impact reshaped video game copyright and intellectual property law.

by Mathelene

Updated Aug 14, 2023

Advertisement
Who was John Kirby? Know All about John Kirby Nintendo Lawyer
Fresherslive

Who was John Kirby? 

John Joseph Kirby Jr. was an American attorney who gained recognition for his notable achievements in the legal field. Born on October 22, 1939, Kirby's career spanned several decades, during which he made a significant impact on the world of intellectual property law.

Article continues below advertisement

One of Kirby's most famous cases was his defense of Nintendo in a copyright dispute against Universal Studios in 1984. The case revolved around the character of Donkey Kong, a popular video game character created by Nintendo. Universal Studios claimed that Donkey Kong infringed upon their copyright for the King Kong character.

Kirby successfully argued that the character of Donkey Kong was distinct from King Kong, highlighting the differences in appearance, personality, and storyline. His defense focused on the idea that copyright only protects specific expressions of ideas, not general concepts or themes. Kirby's argument ultimately convinced the court, leading to a victory for Nintendo and solidifying the legal precedent for video game copyright protection.

As a result of his successful defense, Nintendo decided to honor Kirby by naming one of their future characters after him. The pink, spherical character Kirby was introduced in 1992 and quickly became a beloved figure in Nintendo's gaming franchise. This act of recognition demonstrated the extent of Kirby's impact on the video game industry and his reputation as a skilled attorney.

Article continues below advertisement

However, Kirby's achievements extended beyond the Nintendo case. Throughout his career, he represented numerous clients in high-profile intellectual property disputes, including major corporations and entertainment companies. His expertise in copyright, trademark, and patent law made him a sought-after legal counsel.

Kirby's legal acumen and dedication to his clients earned him a reputation as a tenacious and formidable attorney. He was known for his meticulous preparation, persuasive arguments, and unwavering commitment to securing favorable outcomes for his clients. His successful track record in intellectual property cases solidified his position as one of the leading attorneys in the field.

Aside from his legal work, Kirby was also actively involved in professional organizations related to intellectual property law. He served as the chairman of the Intellectual Property Law Section of the American Bar Association and was a member of the International Trademark Association and the Copyright Society of America.

Article continues below advertisement

Kirby's contributions to the field of intellectual property law continue to have a lasting impact. His groundbreaking defense in the Nintendo case not only protected the rights of video game creators but also set an important precedent for copyright protection in the digital age. His legacy as a skilled attorney and his dedication to upholding the principles of intellectual property law will be remembered for years to come.

John Kirby Nintendo Lawyer

John Kirby, a former partner at the law firm Mudge Rose, played a pivotal role in one of Nintendo's most famous legal battles: Universal City Studios, Inc. v. Nintendo Co., Ltd. (1984). This landmark case centered around the video game Donkey Kong and the alleged infringement of Universal's rights to the iconic character King Kong.

Kirby's brilliant defense not only secured a victory for Nintendo but also solidified his reputation as the man who "saved Nintendo" during its early foray into the American video game market. Universal Studios claimed that Donkey Kong unlawfully used the character King Kong, which they believed they owned the rights to.

However, Kirby successfully argued that Universal's ownership claim was invalid, relying on a previous legal battle in which Universal had sued RKO Pictures over the rights to King Kong. In that case, the court ruled that the story and characters of King Kong were in the public domain, meaning they belonged to the public and could be used freely. Kirby used this ruling to demonstrate that Universal had no legal basis for claiming ownership of the characters and scenario in Donkey Kong.

Kirby's victory in the Universal City Studios case had far-reaching implications for the video game industry. It not only cemented Nintendo's position as a major player but also established an important legal precedent for the use of characters and concepts in video games. The case highlighted the importance of public domain and fair use principles in an industry that was still in its infancy.

Article continues below advertisement

To express their gratitude for Kirby's instrumental role in their legal triumph, Nintendo presented him with a generous gift: a $30,000 sailboat named the Donkey Kong. This gesture not only recognized Kirby's invaluable contribution but also served as a symbol of their enduring partnership. In addition, Nintendo granted Kirby exclusive worldwide rights to use the Donkey Kong name for sailboats, emphasizing the significance of their association.

Interestingly, the character Kirby, created by Masahiro Sakurai, was named in honor of John Kirby. While the exact details surrounding the naming are not widely known, it is rumored that a copy of the game Kirby's Dream Land was eventually sent to Kirby himself. This gesture not only entertained him but also served as a heartfelt acknowledgment of his role in Nintendo's success.

John Kirby's legacy as Nintendo's heroic lawyer extends far beyond the Donkey Kong case. His expertise and strategic thinking played a vital part in shaping the video game industry and protecting the rights of game developers. His victory in the Universal City Studios case set a precedent that continues to influence copyright and intellectual property law to this day.

Article continues below advertisement

In recognition of his contributions, John Kirby will forever be remembered as the man who safeguarded Nintendo's future and paved the way for the company's remarkable success in the world of video games.

John Kirby Attorney

John Kirby is a distinguished attorney whose career spans over four decades. From his early days as a special assistant to the head of the Civil Rights Division at the United States Department of Justice to his successful private practice, Kirby has made a significant impact in the legal field and beyond. This article delves into Kirby's remarkable journey, highlighting his work in civil rights and his accomplishments as a prominent attorney.

During the 1960s, Kirby worked alongside John Doar, the head of the Civil Rights Division, at the Department of Justice. As a special assistant, he played a crucial role in gathering voting records throughout the South, meticulously documenting instances of discrimination against African-Americans.

Kirby's work, particularly the evidence he gathered on discriminatory voting practices like literacy tests, played a pivotal role in shaping the landmark Voting Rights Act of 1965. This legislation aimed to protect the voting rights of African-Americans and end discriminatory practices that had long plagued the electoral process.

Kirby's commitment to civil rights extended beyond gathering evidence. He found himself personally involved in desegregation efforts, escorting African-American children into formerly segregated schools. These acts of courage and dedication were carried out under the protection of federal marshals, showcasing Kirby's unwavering commitment to equality and justice.

Article continues below advertisement

After leaving the Department of Justice, Kirby transitioned into private practice, where he continued to make a name for himself as an exceptional attorney. He argued before the Supreme Court and served as the chairman of the renowned Wall Street law firm Mudge Rose Guthrie Alexander & Ferdon. Kirby's expertise and strategic approach to litigation made him a sought-after attorney for high-profile cases.

In 1995, when Mudge Rose dissolved, Kirby joined the esteemed international law firm Latham & Watkins LLP. He assumed the role of chair of the New York Litigation Department, where he continued to excel and lead by example. Kirby's legal prowess and dedication to his clients earned him a reputation as a formidable litigator.

Throughout his career, Kirby represented a roster of notable corporations in complex legal disputes. His clients included industry giants such as PepsiCo., General Foods, and Warner-Lambert. Kirby's ability to navigate intricate legal landscapes and secure favorable outcomes for his clients was a testament to his skill and expertise.

Article continues below advertisement

Beyond his legal accomplishments, Kirby's impact extended to public service. He was appointed Deputy Director to the President's Commission on Campus Unrest, established in response to the tragic killings of four students at Kent State University. Kirby's involvement in this commission exemplified his commitment to addressing social issues and finding solutions to promote peace and understanding.

John Kirby Death

John Joseph Kirby, Jr., a beloved member of his family and community, passed away on October 2, 2019, at the age of 79. Surrounded by loved ones, he lost his battle with blood cancer, leaving behind cherished memories and a legacy of kindness and resilience.

John Kirby was a remarkable individual who made a lasting impact on those around him. Known for his warm smile and compassionate nature, he touched the lives of family, friends, and acquaintances alike. His spirit of generosity and willingness to lend a helping hand will be sorely missed by all who knew him.

Throughout his life, John faced challenges with unwavering determination. He demonstrated remarkable strength in his battle against blood cancer, never losing hope and always finding the courage to carry on. His ability to inspire others through his own resilience was truly remarkable.

John's passing is a profound loss to his family, who held a special place in his heart. He was a devoted husband, loving father, and doting grandfather, cherishing every moment spent with his loved ones. His family takes solace in knowing that he left this world surrounded by their love and support.

As we mourn the loss of John Joseph Kirby, Jr., let us also celebrate the life he lived. His memory will forever be etched in the hearts of those he touched, reminding us to embrace each day with kindness, resilience, and love.

Article continues below advertisement

John Kirby Personal Life

John Kirby, the renowned American lawyer and legal scholar, had an eventful personal life. He was married to Susan Cullman, who was the daughter of Edgar M. Cullman. The details surrounding their marriage, such as the date and location, are not provided. However, it is known that Kirby had three children from a previous marriage, although their names and details remain undisclosed. Additionally, Kirby also became a stepfather to Susan's daughter from a previous relationship.

Tragically, John Kirby's life was cut short due to complications from myelodysplastic syndrome. He passed away on October 2, 2019, just 20 days before his 80th birthday. Myelodysplastic syndrome is a group of disorders characterized by abnormal production of blood cells in the bone marrow. The exact circumstances surrounding Kirby's diagnosis and treatment are not provided.

Despite the brevity of the information regarding his personal life, it is evident that John Kirby had a family and loved ones who mourned his loss. His marriage to Susan Cullman, his previous children, and his stepdaughter all played a significant role in his life. Kirby's passing marked the end of an accomplished legal career and left a lasting impact on the legal community.

John Kirby Early Life

John Joseph Kirby was born on October 22, 1939, in Falls Church, Virginia. He was the son of John Joseph Kirby, a lawyer with the federal government, and Rose L. Mangan Kirby, a homemaker. John had two brothers, Peter Kirby and Michael Kirby, and two sisters, Lisa Greissing and Cecelia Wrasse.

In his early years, John Kirby showed promise as a student and leader. He attended Fordham University, where he excelled academically and served as the Student Body President. He was also recognized for his leadership skills and was chosen as a Rhodes scholar.

As a Rhodes scholar, Kirby had the opportunity to pursue further studies at Merton College, Oxford University. He successfully completed both a Bachelor's degree and a Master's degree during his time at Oxford. Additionally, Kirby remained connected to his alma mater, Fordham University, serving as a trustee and a trustee fellow.

After his time at Oxford, Kirby decided to pursue a career in law. He enrolled at the University of Virginia School of Law and obtained his Juris Doctor in 1966. John Kirby's early life was marked by academic achievements, leadership roles, and a dedication to education. These experiences shaped his path and laid the foundation for his future success as a lawyer and government official.

Article continues below advertisement


Disclaimer: The above information is for general informational purposes only. All information on the Site is provided in good faith, however we make no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, regarding the accuracy, adequacy, validity, reliability, availability or completeness of any information on the Site.

Who is John Kirby? - FAQs

1. What was the outcome of the Universal City Studios v. Nintendo case? 

The outcome of the Universal City Studios v. Nintendo case was a victory for Nintendo. The court ruled in favor of Nintendo, stating that the character Donkey Kong did not infringe upon Universal's rights to the character King Kong. 

2. How did John Kirby contribute to the video game industry? 

John Kirby contributed to the video game industry through his successful defense of Nintendo in the Universal City Studios v. Nintendo case. His argument and victory in this case established an important legal precedent for copyright protection in the video game industry. 

3. What other notable cases did John Kirby handle? 

John Kirby handled numerous notable cases throughout his career. Some of these cases involved high-profile intellectual property disputes for major corporations and entertainment companies.

4. What law firm did John Kirby work for? 

John Kirby worked for the law firms Mudge Rose Guthrie Alexander & Ferdon and Latham & Watkins LLP throughout his career. He served as the chairman of Mudge Rose and later joined Latham & Watkins as the chair of the New York Litigation Department.
 

5. What other achievements did John Kirby have? 

In addition to his legal accomplishments, John Kirby served as the chairman of the Intellectual Property Law Section of the American Bar Association.

Advertisement